• Home
  • warrick wynne
  • web 2.0 in schools

teaching and learning

reflecting on teaching, learning and technology in k-12 education

Feed on
Posts
comments

New Paper Restarts the History Wars

August 5, 2006 by warrick




Not entirely sure why I continue to be suprised at self-serving politicians who reckon they know what schools should be doing better than the professional educators in schools themselves. But I do! I think I need a new blog category: stuff that governments,business and other interest groups think schools should be doing other than educating students. Nah, too long.

I’ve blogged about this Federal Government’s interventionist approach with regard to reporting and assessment, literacy, and even spelling as well as Australian history and whose stories anyway. In the AGE today Education Miister Bishop argues for more facts and dates. That’s what history is about, facts and dates!

Perhaps Julie Bishop could sponsor a poetry competition to set Year 10 students hearts racing, modelled on this old history narrative…

‘In fourteen hundred and ninety-two, Columbus sailed the ocean blue..’

THE history wars are about to be reignited, thanks to a paper that argues that Australian history in schools focuses “excessively” on topics such as the Vietnam War and the Whitlam government while ignoring issues such as economic development.

The paper, commissioned by the Federal Government for consideration at a national Australian history summit this month, also stresses the need to tackle the common perception that “Australian history is crap … ’cause nothing happened”‘.

Its author, Gregory Melleuish, says school is the only significant contact most people have with the study of history. But he argues there is a tendency for Australian history lessons to “exclude or marginalise” many significant elements.

“These include economic development issues, middle-Australia, people of religious belief and the churches,” Associate Professor Melleuish says in the paper, which outlines what he believes students should be taught by the end of year 10.

“It is necessary that a place be made for these elements.”

Education Minister Julie Bishop announced the summit last month, claiming that not enough students were learning Australian history, there was too much political bias and that not enough pivotal facts and dates were being taught.

She said it was essential that a structured, narrative approach was taken and every child should know when and why James Cook sailed along the east coast of Australia.

Original article HERE.

I’ll try to find if the report is available online.

Posted in education-news | No Comments


Create a free edublog to get your own comment avatar (and more!)

Comments are closed.

  • Recent Posts

    • Moving Day
    • Snowy Mountains
    • Learning Axioms from EduCon 2.1
    • Lawyers, Guns and Money
    • AGE fails test on accuracy and hypocrisy
  • Recent Comments

    • Steve Hubbard on learning management systems
    • Observations & Developments » Post Topic » Education Reform: History and Politics on What troubles me about a national curriculum
    • Graham Wegner on Finland Rules!
    • Penny on So not at work this week
    • Linda on So not at work this week
  •  

    August 2006
    M T W T F S S
    « Jul   Sep »
     123456
    78910111213
    14151617181920
    21222324252627
    28293031  
  • all my web sites

    • EnglishBook Blog
    • my original teaching and learning blog (moved here in 2006)
    • poetry pages
    • teaching and learning wikispace
    • the tabletpc wiki
  • Blogroll

    • k12 Online Conference
    • Open Educator
  • blogs I like

    • Australian Edubloggers
    • Darcy Norman
    • EduBeacon
    • Teaching Generation Z
    • The Open Classroom
  • podcasts I like

    • EdTech Talk
    • GenTech
  • web 2.0 learning

    • australian edubloggers
    • Class Blogmeister
    • edblogger news
    • TeacherTube
  • wikis I like

    • School Computing
  • Subscribe by email via feedburner

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

  • Meta

    • Register
    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • WordPress.org

Theme: MistyLook by Sadish. Hosted by Edublogs.